Private Credit News Weekly Issue #97: The 5 Things You Need to Monitor
Capital markets reopen for BDCs as PIMCO backstops Blue Owl, but Medallia and Affordable Care defaults expose what's coming
Sponsorship: Private Debt News reaches institutional investors, credit professionals, and LP decision-makers. Early sponsor rates available. Contact us here or reply directly to this email.
Two big private equity loans just defaulted.
Medallia can’t repay roughly $3 billion in loans from Blackstone, KKR, Apollo, and others. Thoma Bravo is walking away from the $5.1 billion it sank into the company in 2021, handing the keys to creditors. Lenders had Medallia at 80 cents in December. They marked it to 60 cents this month. The restructuring under discussion would slash Medallia’s debt to $1 billion to $1.4 billion against $200 million of EBITDA, with creditors taking 100% of equity.
Blackstone and KKR are simultaneously restructuring a $1.4 billion loan to Affordable Care, the dental services business owned by Harvest Partners. BCRED marked that loan to 69.8 cents. Together, Medallia and Affordable Care drove BCRED’s non-performing loans to a record 2.4% of its $80.5 billion portfolio.
Then PIMCO showed up. The firm bought every dollar of Blue Owl Capital Corp’s $400 million bond offering at a 6.5% yield, the first BDC bond sale in more than six weeks. Blue Owl shares jumped 17% afterward. Spreads tightened 25 bps. Goldman Sachs’s direct lending fund followed a day later with $750 million against a $500 million target, drawing nearly $3 billion of orders. BCRED priced $850 million Wednesday at 230 bps over Treasuries with $4.3 billion of demand.
Retail flows tell a different story. Non-listed BDCs took in $4.9 billion in Q1, down 59% from $12 billion a year earlier. Redemptions topped $15 billion, breaching 5% caps at most major funds.
Banks finally disclosed exposure. JPMorgan leads at $50 billion, then Wells Fargo at $36.2 billion, Citi at $22 billion, Morgan Stanley at $20.1 billion, and Bank of America at $20 billion. Eleven banks total around $185 billion. JPMorgan is also building its own private credit operation, deploying tens of billions through asset management.
Moody’s pointed at the 2028 maturity wall. UBS sees defaults doubling to 9-10% this year as the SaaSpocalypse unfolds. Diameter’s Jonathan Lewinsohn called it a “reckoning threatening” the industry, with manager dispersion that’s “never happened before.”
Some funds navigate this. Others don’t. Medallia just showed which side of the line Thoma Bravo’s $5.1 billion landed on.
Key Market Themes
1. Medallia Hands Keys to Creditors as $5.1 Billion Thoma Bravo Bet Implodes
Medallia can no longer repay about $3 billion of loans from firms including Blackstone, KKR, and Apollo. Lenders are negotiating to take control from Thoma Bravo, which will likely lose the $5.1 billion it invested in 2021. Blackstone and KKR valued their Medallia loans at 80 cents on the dollar in December before slashing them to 60 cents this month.
Medallia’s troubles started before AI. Interest expense jumped in 2022 when the Fed raised rates. Sales suffered from competition with Qualtrics, another PE-owned software company with debt problems of its own.
The credit crunch hit because Medallia’s loans contained provisions requiring Thoma Bravo to inject more equity if earnings missed targets. Thoma Bravo had until end of June to put in cash. Last week, it told Blackstone it’s handing over the keys.
Private credit funds hired Alvarez & Marsal to vet Medallia’s finances and aim to restructure outside bankruptcy court. They’re considering cutting loans to $1 billion to $1.4 billion, or five to seven times Medallia’s $200 million EBITDA, with creditors receiving 100% of equity.
What Medallia signals
Medallia is the test case private credit feared. Many firms concentrated 20% or more of their funds in software loans. UBS analysts said the SaaSpocalypse will likely double default rates to 9-10% this year.
The 80-to-60 cent move in three months shows how fast software valuations crater when sponsors stop supporting refinancings. Apollo’s John Zito reportedly told investors “I literally think all the marks are wrong” about private equity values on buyouts including Medallia.
Thoma Bravo founder Orlando Bravo conceded Medallia was a mistake and the firm paid too much. Medallia’s failure suggests 2021-vintage software buyouts at peak multiples won’t survive higher rates plus AI uncertainty plus the leverage these deals carried into the storm.
2. PIMCO Buys Entire $400M Blue Owl Bond, Reopens BDC Capital Markets
Blue Owl needed a win. Shares had collapsed nearly 50% from peak. Clients sought to pull unprecedented sums. Activists and short sellers were piling on. Then Morgan Stanley pitched a bond sale that would reaffirm Blue Owl’s access to capital markets and reinforce its investment-grade standing.
The catch: Blue Owl had to offer a premium. Blue Owl Capital Corp’s 2.5-year notes priced at 6.5%, or 270 bps over similar Treasuries. PIMCO emerged as the buyer of the entire $400 million offering after approaching Blue Owl directly about taking down the deal.
Blue Owl had partnered with PIMCO last year to finance a Meta data center project. Executives recognized the signal Pimco’s involvement would send and accepted the premium. Blue Owl shares have jumped 17% since the sale. Spreads on the bonds tightened by about 25 bps.
The deal was the first BDC bond sale in more than six weeks. A day later, Goldman Sachs’s direct lending fund raised $750 million, exceeding its $500 million target after drawing nearly $3 billion in orders. Blackstone’s BCRED followed Wednesday with $850 million, attracting $4.3 billion of demand at 230 bps over Treasuries.
Why PIMCO matters here
PIMCO buying every dollar of Blue Owl’s bond at 6.5% sends the strongest signal the institutional market has produced in months. Same firm whose president called loans for sale “pretty bad” two weeks ago just underwrote $400 million of Blue Owl debt. That’s not contradiction. It’s precision.
PIMCO buys investment-grade BDC bonds backed by diversified loan portfolios at attractive spreads. PIMCO walks away from individual bad loans being dumped at discounts. Managers got the message: investment-grade structures with verifiable cash flows clear the market. Stressed individual loans without clearing prices don’t.
The 270 bps premium Blue Owl paid versus similar Treasuries was cheap relative to what continued share price collapse would have cost. PIMCO taking the entire deal rather than syndicating suggests current pricing represents attractive entry rather than market-clearing level.
3. Banks Disclose $185 Billion in Private Credit Exposure as JPMorgan Plans Own Push
Major US banks disclosed approximately $185 billion in private credit exposure during recent earnings calls. JPMorgan leads at $50 billion, followed by Wells Fargo at $36.2 billion, Citi at $22 billion, Morgan Stanley at $20.1 billion, and Bank of America at $20 billion. KeyCorp disclosed $10.9 billion, US Bancorp $9.6 billion, PNC $7 billion, Citizens $4.1 billion, Truist $4 billion, and Fifth Third $1.4 billion.
JPMorgan’s $4.3 trillion asset management arm is committing to a strategy that will deploy tens of billions into loans sourced by the firm’s commercial bankers. The bank is talking with institutional investors to raise several billion dollars to start and has secured some commitments.
The push echoes Citigroup’s 2024 partnership with Apollo on $25 billion of deals over five years and Wells Fargo’s 2023 venture with Centerbridge on a $5 billion fund. JPMorgan’s twist: housing the strategy within JPMorgan Asset Management’s fixed-income business rather than alternatives, reflecting the bank’s view that public and private credit markets will converge.
Jeff Bracchitta, brought over from JPMorgan’s commercial and investment bank, has recruited about a dozen specialists for the team. The bank earmarked $50 billion of its $4.9 trillion balance sheet for direct lending and holds another $50 billion in back leverage to private credit funds.
The banks reentry decoded
The $185 billion disclosure resolves months of speculation about exposure size. Numbers are large but distributed. JPMorgan’s $50 billion sits at roughly 1% of its balance sheet.
Dimon publicly warning about private credit while JPMorgan builds the largest bank-affiliated private credit operation tells you the strategy. Stake the territory while competitors are weakened. The Monroe Capital deal collapsed in 2024, so JPMorgan is building organically.
Banks deploying capital into private credit while pulling back leverage from existing managers creates the new dynamic. Banks become competitors. The 150 bps over SOFR fund finance pricing that helped goose private credit returns gets reconsidered when banks can deploy that capital directly into loans they own.
4. Q1 BDC Inflows Plunge 59% as Retail Exodus Accelerates
Non-listed BDCs attracted just $4.9 billion in Q1, down 59% from over $12 billion a year earlier per Robert A. Stanger & Co. data based on 23 publicly registered BDCs. The figures don’t account for redemption requests, which topped $15 billion across the industry and exceeded 5% caps at most major funds.
BCRED, one of the few large non-traded BDCs to meet redemptions in full, drew about $1.3 billion in inflows, down 60% from a year earlier. Blue Owl’s flagship fund, which capped withdrawals after investors sought to redeem 22% of shares, took in $580 million. Blue Owl Technology Income Corp added about $77 million. Combined, Blue Owl’s funds saw nearly 70% less inflow than the same period last year.
Ares Management is planning a significantly smaller flagship US direct lending fund than its previous record-breaking vehicle. The Ares Strategic Income Fund saw inflows slow by about 53% in Q1 from a year earlier.
Moody’s flagged refinancing risk building from 2028 onward, particularly for software borrowers. “An important test for BDCs will be how the sector addresses loan maturities,” Clay Montgomery, vice president at Moody’s, said. The maturities start accelerating in 2028 and 2029.
The retail flow inflection
A 59% drop in inflows is a regime change. Non-listed BDCs built their model on consistent retail accumulation funding new loan deployment. Without that flow, funds either deploy from balance sheet, slow originations, or lean on institutional capital with different return expectations.
The redemption-to-inflow ratio matters most. Blue Owl’s flagship took in $580 million while facing requests to redeem 22% of shares. Even capped at 5%, that’s roughly $1.7 billion of net outflows on a $34 billion fund, or 5% net asset reduction in one quarter. Sustained at that pace, the fund shrinks 20% annually before any mark changes.
Ares planning a smaller flagship fund acknowledges new reality. Vintage 2026 funds will deploy at better entry points than 2024 vintages but at smaller scale. Less capital chasing the same deal pipeline could improve underwriting discipline. It also compresses fee income for managers built on AUM growth.
5. Listed BDCs Trade at 86% of Book as Bargain Hunters Buy the Selloff
Bargain hunters are scooping up listed BDCs after valuations dropped to their lowest since 2022. The Cliffwater BDC Index sat at 80.5% of book value in late March before recovering to 86% by Thursday. Ares Capital Corp closed as low as 87.5% of book in March, trading closer to 93% Thursday.
Some investors are running an arbitrage trade between unlisted and listed BDCs. For non-listed BDCs, investors get NAV when cashing out, though funds may limit total quarterly withdrawals. Listed BDCs trade actively and can sell below NAV.
“We’ve seen that in our BDC fund, where investors have said that they are liquidating their private holdings and buying the public funds for less, and we’ve seen significant inflows into our fund because of that,” said Mike Petro, a portfolio manager at Putnam Investments who runs an ETF that buys BDCs.
Not every investor is buying. Software loans make up about 20% of BDC portfolios per Barclays. “You don’t want to catch a falling knife,” said Scott Opsal, CIO at Leuthold Group. “These BDCs don’t have enough of a yield pickup to offset the unknown black hole of software loans that could hurt you since you can get decent yield from investment grade debt or a junk bond fund.”
US investment-grade bonds gained 0.4% YTD through Thursday’s close. Junk bonds returned 1.2%. Listed BDCs dropped 7.8% per the Cliffwater BDC Index.
The arbitrage opportunity
The unlisted-to-listed BDC arbitrage exposes a structural inefficiency. Same managers, similar portfolios, different prices. Investors selling unlisted at NAV and buying listed at 86% of book capture roughly 14% upfront, assuming portfolios genuinely match.
Whether that arbitrage closes depends on Q1 BDC earnings starting April 28. If markdowns prove limited and dividend coverage holds, listed BDCs return toward 95%+ of book. Severe markdowns push listed BDCs further below book and force unlisted BDCs to mark down to match.
Fitch’s Chelsea Richardson expects “pressure from markdowns in software investments during the first quarter given what’s happened with spreads in that sector.” Even without actual credit losses, market-related moves will translate into lower valuations.
Deals of Note
Affordable Care - Blackstone and KKR leading restructuring of $1.4B loan; BCRED marked at 69.8 cents
Medallia - Lenders negotiating to take control from Thoma Bravo; loans cut from 80 to 60 cents, considering reduction to $1B-$1.4B with 100% equity to creditors
Blue Owl Capital Corp - $400M bond at 6.5% yield, entirely purchased by PIMCO in first BDC bond sale in 6+ weeks
Goldman Sachs Private Credit Corp - $750M bond raise after $500M target, attracted nearly $3B in orders
BCRED - $850M bond sale at 230 bps over Treasuries, drew $4.3B in demand
AirAsia Aviation Group - Deutsche Bank marketing $230M private credit deal for Malaysian budget airline
Recordati - Banks and private credit lenders working on financing for CVC Capital’s potential acquisition of Italian drugmaker
Sotheby’s - KKR providing up to $100M secured against fees clients owe on auction purchases
NBA European Expansion - Apollo, Ares, and Sixth Street in early discussions to fund league’s European expansion
The Reality Check
Medallia handing keys to creditors and Thoma Bravo eating $5.1 billion isn’t anomalous. It’s the prototype. Software companies bought at peak multiples in 2021 with 7x+ leverage and provisions requiring sponsor equity at performance shortfalls were vulnerable from inception. AI just collapsed the timeline.
The 60-cent mark on Medallia debt sets a benchmark. If a 80-to-60 cent move in three months represents the path for stressed software credits, the 26% software exposure across BDC portfolios faces 5-15% portfolio-wide markdowns over the next 12-18 months.
PIMCO buying every dollar of Blue Owl’s $400 million bond at 6.5% draws the line. Investment-grade BDC structures with diversified portfolios clear at current spreads. Individual stressed loans don’t clear at any reasonable price. PIMCO took both sides correctly: bought the structure, walked from the loans.
Q1 inflows down 59% with redemptions topping $15 billion creates compounding pressure. Even funds meeting redemptions watch AUM shrink, fees fall, and capacity to support stressed loans through workout disappear with it.
Diameter’s “reckoning” and Sycamore Tree’s “culling of the weaker herd” point to the same destination. Some funds navigate this. Others don’t. Manager dispersion replaces the consistent returns that defined the asset class for a decade. The genuine shift isn’t whether private credit survives. It’s which managers do.
