Private Debt News Weekly Issue #61: Liquid Wrappers, Illiquid Assets, Infinite Problems
Retail experiments show mixed results while institutional capital flows remain strong
Follow me on Twitter. Interested in sponsoring Private Debt News? Discounted rates available for early sponsors—get in touch here or via e-mail.
Private credit is navigating complex structural tensions as it expands across different investor bases and product formats. The industry is simultaneously pursuing retail distribution through ETFs and interval funds while maintaining strong institutional fundraising momentum.
State Street’s private credit ETF has gathered $145 million in assets after several months, while PGIM successfully raised $4.2 billion for its latest direct lending fund. The divergent outcomes reflect different investor preferences and product-market fit challenges across retail and institutional segments.
Industry leaders offer contrasting views on retirement plan access, with Sixth Street's Josh Easterly urging caution while Centerbridge’s Jeff Aronson sees strong potential. Senator Elizabeth Warren has raised concerns about rating practices as S&P Global reports 11% revenue growth from private credit ratings. Brown University completed a $500 million private loan amid federal funding uncertainties.
These developments highlight the industry’s evolution as it addresses diverse capital sources, regulatory frameworks, and market structures while maintaining its core lending focus.
Key Market Themes
1. ETF Products Face Product-Market Fit Challenges
State Street's PRIV ETF has attracted $145 million in assets with backing from Apollo Global Management. The fund holds 22% in Apollo-sourced investments and approximately 7% in direct private credit, according to CFRA Research. BondBloxx and Virtus have launched competing products using CLO structures to access private credit markets.
SEC regulations limit ETFs to 15% illiquid holdings, creating structural constraints for private credit exposure. Apollo provides liquidity backstops for up to 25% daily redemptions to address regulatory requirements.
Market Dynamics
Daily liquidity expectations create operational complexity for inherently illiquid underlying assets. Product structure innovations continue as managers seek solutions for liquidity mismatches.
2. Retirement Plan Access Generates Industry Debate
Sixth Street's Josh Easterly expressed concerns about individual investor protections in private credit, noting complexity around financial metrics and fee structures. Centerbridge's Jeff Aronson views private credit as appropriate for 401(k) participants who understand the yield-oriented, less liquid characteristics.
BlackRock plans to launch target-date funds with 5-20% private market allocations by mid-2026. Trump administration support for private market access could accelerate adoption across the $12 trillion retirement savings market.
Regulatory Considerations
Senator Elizabeth Warren has requested stress testing of private credit firms, highlighting ongoing regulatory attention as the asset class expands into broader investor bases.
3. Rating Agency Business Expands Amid Oversight Questions
S&P Global's private markets revenue increased 11% year-over-year in Q2, driven by middle-market CLO ratings and asset-backed securities. Moody's reported 50% growth in private credit deal volume. Insurance company demand for rated investments supports this trend as insurers increase private credit allocations.
Senator Elizabeth Warren raised questions about rating practices, referencing Egan-Jones, which has rated over 3,000 private deals with approximately 20 analysts. Rating agencies emphasize consistent methodologies across public and private markets.
Industry Evolution
Rating demand reflects the asset class's institutionalization as insurance companies and other regulated entities increase allocations while maintaining compliance requirements.
4. Bank-Private Credit Partnerships Accelerate
Fifth Third and Eldridge announced a partnership targeting $2-3 billion in financing over three years. Fifth Third will source opportunities through 400 commercial bankers while Eldridge provides underwriting for deals outside the bank's parameters. Similar structures include KeyCorp-Blackstone and PNC-TCW partnerships.
Banks seek fee generation without balance sheet utilization, while private credit firms gain access to established origination networks. These partnerships address different risk appetites and capital constraints.
Strategic Implications
Partnership models allow both banks and private credit firms to serve broader client needs while managing their respective operational and regulatory constraints.
5. Higher Education Sector Adapts to Funding Environment
Brown University secured a $500 million private loan at 4.44% following a $300 million facility in April. The borrowing follows university warnings about financial challenges related to federal funding changes. Brown's $7.2 billion endowment ranks smallest among Ivy League institutions.
Higher education institutions are utilizing private markets as traditional funding sources face uncertainty. This represents private credit's expansion into sectors previously served primarily by public markets.
Sector Dynamics
University borrowing patterns reflect broader changes in federal funding policies and institutions' need for flexible capital sources during transitional periods.
6. Institutional Fundraising Momentum Continues
PGIM raised $4.2 billion for its Senior Loan Opportunities II fund, representing 75% growth over its $2.4 billion predecessor. The fund focuses on US, European, and Australian middle-market lending across sponsored and non-sponsored borrowers.
Strong institutional demand contrasts with retail product adoption patterns, suggesting different investor segments value distinct characteristics of private credit exposure.
Market Assessment
Fundraising success indicates continued institutional confidence in private credit strategies while highlighting the importance of appropriate product-investor matching.
Deals of Note
Brown University — $500M private loan at 4.44% for operational flexibility
PGIM — $4.2B raised for Senior Loan Opportunities II fund
Fifth Third/Eldridge — $2-3B partnership framework announced
State Street PRIV ETF — $145M in assets under management
Apollo ACRED — Tokenized private credit product gaining traction
Forward Outlook
ETF product development continues as managers address liquidity structure challenges
Retirement plan access discussions advance pending regulatory clarity
Rating agency practices face increased scrutiny as market grows
Bank partnership models expand across regional and national institutions
Higher education borrowing patterns evolve with funding environment changes
Institutional fundraising maintains momentum despite market maturation
Final Takeaway
Private credit is navigating a complex evolution as it expands across different investor segments, product structures, and market applications. The industry demonstrates strong institutional fundraising momentum while working through challenges in retail distribution and regulatory frameworks.
PGIM’s $4.2 billion institutional success alongside State Street's $145 million ETF results illustrates how different investor bases respond to varying product characteristics. University sector borrowing, rating agency growth, and bank partnership expansion reflect the asset class's broadening applications beyond traditional middle-market lending.
The $1.7 trillion private credit market now encompasses diverse strategies from university operational funding to tokenized investment products. This expansion creates opportunities while introducing new operational complexities and regulatory considerations.
Structural questions around liquidity, investor suitability, and market infrastructure remain as the industry scales. Different product formats serve different investor needs, but each requires appropriate matching of asset characteristics with investor expectations and regulatory frameworks.
The industry’s continued growth depends on successfully managing these structural challenges while maintaining the credit discipline and risk management that attracted institutional capital initially. Private credit’s future development will likely reflect how well it adapts to serve diverse capital sources while preserving its core value propositions for borrowers and lenders.