Private Debt News Weekly Issue #59: Retail Invades, Banks Retaliate, and Valuation Gets Weird
401(k)s, tokens, and lawsuit bait. Private credit’s newest frontier is the average investor.
Follow me on Twitter. Interested in sponsoring Private Debt News? Discounted rates available for early sponsors—get in touch here or via e-mail.
Private credit is expanding. But it is moving into places it was never designed to go.
Retail money is pouring in through target-date funds, tokenized wrappers, and NAV-based interval products. Robinhood is turning model-based valuations into tradeable exposure. The White House is opening 401(k) channels to direct lending. Fidelity just raised over $700 million from high-net-worth investors for opportunistic credit.
At the same time, the core of the system is starting to creak. Elizabeth Warren is questioning private credit ratings. Australia is probing loan valuations and fund governance. And borrowers like Finastra are walking away from private deals in favor of cheaper syndicated debt from banks.
The structures are holding. For now. But if too many investors want out at once, the unwind will not be orderly.
Key Market Themes
401(k) Access to Private Credit Is Around the Corner
The White House is finalizing an executive order that would allow defined-contribution retirement plans to invest directly in private credit funds. SEC Chair Paul Atkins is publicly supportive. Behind the scenes, BlackRock, Empower, and JPMorgan are already structuring products to capture this demand.
BlackRock’s latest target-date fund includes a private debt allocation sleeve, while Empower, with $1.8 trillion in AUM, plans to offer private credit through its retirement infrastructure. JPMorgan’s new “strategic financing solutions” group is focused on customized credit structures aimed at long-dated pools like pensions and DC plans.
Why It Matters:
This is permanent capital chasing non-tradable paper. But 401(k) investors expect transparency, liquidity, and pricing discipline. When those collide with drawdowns, gates, and NAV adjustments, the reputational blowback won’t stop at the fund level.
Senator Warren Targets Inflated Credit Ratings
Senator Elizabeth Warren sent letters to S&P, Moody’s, Fitch, and Egan-Jones, raising concerns about overly generous ratings on private credit deals. She singled out Egan-Jones for assigning more than 3,000 investment-grade ratings with a staff of just 20 analysts. Her warning: the behavior resembles the run-up to the 2008 crisis.
She also sent a separate request to the Financial Stability Oversight Council, asking for a formal review of the $95 billion in bank loans extended to private credit funds. Her concern: banks are not only lending to funds, they’re also buying the paper the funds originate, creating circular exposure.
Why It Matters:
Many private credit deals are only rated IG to unlock insurance flows or low-cost capital structures. If the arbitrage window closes, spreads widen, capital charges rise, and allocation models break down across the insurance channel.
Goldman Sachs Overtakes Blackstone. Again.
Goldman Sachs stock is up 25 percent year to date, reclaiming the valuation lead over Blackstone. Its trading and client financing arms generated $4.3 billion in equity revenues, the highest ever recorded.
By contrast, shares of Apollo, Blue Owl, and Blackstone have all lagged. Execution risk, delayed exits, and slowdowns in deployment have weighed on returns.
Why It Matters:
This isn’t just a stock chart. It’s a signal that capital formation is rotating. In a rate-volatility environment, banks with trading and advisory arms are regaining their edge. That means more M&A mandates, more refinancing volume, and less desperation from sponsors to take private debt at any price.
Morgan Stanley Wins Back a $4 Billion Refi from Private Credit
Finastra, the financial software firm backed by Vista Equity Partners, is refinancing its existing private credit facility through a $4 billion syndicated deal led by Morgan Stanley. The deal includes a $2.55 billion first-lien, €600 million euro term loan, and $350 million second-lien.
Finastra borrowed $5.3 billion from Oak Hill and others in 2023, in what was one of the largest private credit transactions ever done. The original paper priced at SOFR + 725 basis points.
Why It Matters:
Finastra’s move back to syndicated credit isn’t about sentiment. It’s about price. Banks are now competitive again on execution, flexibility, and cost of capital. Sponsors will follow the math.
Grubhub Owner Wonder Seeks $500 Million PIK Loan
Wonder Group, which acquired Grubhub last year, is seeking $400 to $500 million in new financing with a payment-in-kind (PIK) feature and an expected all-in yield near 13 percent.
The company is working with private credit lenders to refinance Grubhub’s $500 million in legacy 5.5 percent notes. New York’s cap on delivery fees and recent legal settlements have weighed on the unit’s performance.
Why It Matters:
A 13 percent PIK toggle in 2025 isn’t a growth play. It’s a liquidity preservation move. Lenders doing these deals are chasing optionality and warrant coverage, not yield. If this one clears, the late-cycle trade still has legs.
CVC Plans $12 Billion Recap of Sports Assets
CVC Capital Partners is preparing a £9 billion ($12 billion) recapitalization of its global sports rights portfolio. The firm owns stakes in Six Nations Rugby, La Liga, and Indian Premier League cricket, among others.
The plan involves creating a holding company, SportsCo, and raising new debt alongside a possible minority stake sale or IPO.
Why It Matters:
This is the refinancing blueprint for aging sponsor assets. Roll them up, raise liquidity, and defer the exit clock. If CVC pulls this off, expect more sponsors to pursue similar credit-led recap models in lieu of full exits.
Secondaries Start Setting the Real NAV
Coller Capital just closed a $6.8 billion secondaries fund dedicated to private credit. Blackstone’s Strategic Partners is not far behind with its own standalone secondaries strategy. With many direct lending funds now 3 to 5 years old, managers are increasingly turning to the secondary market to recycle assets, create liquidity for LPs, or clean up performance drag.
Unlike primary NAVs, which are based on models and manager estimates, secondaries reflect actual transaction prices—often at a discount.
Why It Matters:
Secondaries are becoming the real price discovery engine for a market built on model-based marks. If tradeable prices diverge from fund NAVs, expect fundraising pressure, valuation write-downs, and a new round of scrutiny on internal fair value practices.
Deals of Note
Finastra — $4B syndicated refi replaces 2023-era private credit
Wonder Group — $500M refinancing of Grubhub with PIK and 13% yield
CVC SportsCo — prepping $12B recap with potential IPO
Fidelity — $729M closed for second vintage opportunistic credit fund
Blue Owl — $850M raised for asset-based lending via private wealth channel
Forward Outlook
Retail capital will continue flowing into interval funds and feeder structures, but redemption governance will face scrutiny
Insurance allocations are reaching peak saturation. Valuation and rating pressure could slow new flows
Tokenized credit exposure is likely to face regulatory pushback in the U.S., particularly if sold without issuer approval
Banks are now back in the refi mix. Expect club deals and takeouts to intensify
Secondary liquidity desks will expand, but NAV friction and LP pushback remain underreported risks
Final Takeaway
The most dangerous moment in private credit is not the crisis. It is the calm.
The loans are still performing. The inflows are still coming. The products still work on paper. But beneath the surface, the system is getting stretched.
Secondaries are quietly setting lower NAVs. Retail products are promising flexibility without the liquidity to back it up. Insurance capital is still flowing in, but only if the ratings hold. And when the assumptions behind those marks start to wobble, so will the capital.
This is not 2008. It is not 2020. But it does not have to be a crash for real damage to occur. All it takes is one mismatch. One redemption wave. One failed gate.
Private credit is still the trade. But the risks are shifting from credit to structure. From borrower to fund. From yield to liquidity.
Know what you own. Know who else owns it. And know what happens when they try to sell.
Stay sharp.
Great coverage. Kudos.
I’m really curious what the secondary effects will be if insurance companies are forced to downgrade or outright remove private ratings. For example, will the increased debt capital require rebalancing via equity sales? Any massive downgrades to the parent companies, constraining future debt issuance or causing liquidity issues. I can’t believe the NAIC has allowed this mess to continue as far as it has.
Fantastic lette - would be great to have links to the original articles/sources, so we could review them in detail.