Private Debt News Weekly Issue #52: Everyone Wants In, No One Wants to Blink
The Fed wakes up, Apollo wants daily pricing, and retail still doesn’t get it
Just launched a Twitter account. Follow me here!
Welcome back to Private Debt News Weekly, where the capital keeps flowing—but the cracks are getting harder to ignore.
This week, the Federal Reserve officially flagged private credit as a risk vector, pointing to opaque structures and hidden leverage flowing through bank balance sheets. At the same time, Apollo is pushing to build a tradable marketplace for private loans, promising real-time pricing in an asset class designed to avoid exactly that.
State Street’s private credit ETF remains DOA, even as interval funds rake in retail flows. And in a blow to the asset class’s core value proposition, Dimensional Fund Advisors released 40 years of data showing that junk bonds have outperformed private credit—once you strip away the marketing gloss.
Meanwhile, the European Central Bank is well past warnings. It's demanding banks quantify, justify, and clean up their private market exposure—now.
Let’s get into it.
Key Market Themes
1. The Fed Sees What Everyone Else Has Ignored
The Boston Fed just drew a direct line between private credit’s current structures and pre-2008 collateralized debt obligations. Their concern? Banks are providing the senior capital—warehouse lines, revolvers, and TRS facilities—to funds that are aggressively lending further down the risk curve.
This isn’t theoretical. These credit lines are often callable, lightly monitored, and rarely stress-tested across market cycles. It’s the same dynamic that blew up in 2007. Only this time, it’s off-balance-sheet, less regulated, and much bigger.
What to Watch:
The Fed isn’t just concerned about default risk—it’s worried about liquidity chain reactions. If private credit funds face redemptions or mark stress, bank-funded capital could disappear overnight, pulling collateral prices with it.
2. Apollo Tries to Rewrite the Playbook
Apollo is working with JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs, and Citi to build a real-time secondary market for private credit loans. The idea: turn locked-up, bespoke paper into scalable, tradable product. The firm has already executed over $3 billion in transactions since Q4 and is accelerating that push into H2.
Why? Liquidity brings scale. Tradability attracts retail and wealth managers. And faster syndication reduces Apollo’s warehousing risk.
But it’s not just a plumbing upgrade. If Apollo forces transparent pricing and real-time quotes, it could trigger valuation pressure across the industry—especially for managers whose reported marks are disconnected from observable markets.
The Tension:
Private credit’s advantage has always been mark control, not mark-to-market. If Apollo forces the industry into a world of daily prices and bid-ask spreads, managers with “smooth” NAVs may find themselves facing some hard questions.
3. State Street’s Private Credit ETF Still Isn’t Working
The $PRIV ETF, designed to give retail investors exposure to Apollo-originated private loans, continues to underwhelm. Just two days of net inflows since its February launch. Less than $60 million in AUM. No signs of institutional pickup.
Now, State Street is filing for a short-duration version, targeting 1–3 year paper instead of 6. But the structure—daily liquidity for illiquid assets—is still fundamentally flawed.
By contrast, interval funds are quietly raising billions, offering limited redemptions, no daily NAV, and friendlier pricing optics.
Bottom Line:
Retail wants private credit, but not in a form that contradicts the product’s DNA. ETFs may be dead on arrival. The future is in semi-liquid wrappers that don’t pretend to be something they’re not.
4. Dimensional Says the Alpha Isn’t Real
Dimensional Fund Advisors looked at 40+ years of data and came to a sharp conclusion: junk bonds have outperformed private credit on a risk-adjusted basis since 1980. Even accounting for illiquidity, the so-called premium didn’t show up consistently—and when it did, it often got eaten by fees and leverage drag.
Private credit may offer access to off-the-run borrowers and customization, but the idea that it’s structurally superior? Not supported by the numbers.
Why This Matters:
If LPs stop believing that private credit delivers outperformance, it becomes a commoditized yield product. That means lower fees, more scrutiny, and a distribution race rather than a returns story.
5. The ECB Stops Asking Nicely
The European Central Bank has moved from concern to enforcement. It’s now conducting on-site exams, reviewing loan-level data, and demanding remediation plans from major banks with material exposure to private credit funds.
The asks:
Aggregate and disclose all fund-related exposures, including NAV lines and revolvers
Justify internal ratings when external credit data is absent
Stress-test exposure to capital calls, redemptions, and asset sales
One major French bank has already received a formal visit. Others are insuring exposures or turning down new fund finance mandates altogether.
The Shift:
This isn’t just Europe being cautious. It’s regulatory friction hitting real capital formation. If this trend migrates to U.S. bank supervisors, the leverage behind private credit could get a lot more expensive—or dry up altogether.
Forward Outlook
The days of unmonitored bank leverage are numbered. Whether it's the ECB or the Fed, the focus is shifting toward fund finance and senior funding lines.
Apollo’s experiment will either unlock scale or unravel the façade. If tradable private credit becomes real, expect mark-to-market volatility, regulatory interest, and LP pressure.
Retail isn’t giving up—but it’s getting smarter. Expect continued growth in interval funds, feeder vehicles, and semi-liquid alternatives, not ETFs.
Performance narratives are changing. As more data debunks outperformance, the sales pitch will shift to access, complexity, and diversification—not alpha.
Secondary liquidity is coming—but slowly. Expect more BWICs, NAV trades, and secondaries in H2—but true depth will take time.
Final Takeaway
Private credit used to be simple: more yield, less volatility, no questions asked. That era is over.
Now the Fed is watching. The ECB is interrogating. Apollo wants to make it tradable. And LPs are asking whether it even delivers what they were sold.
This is still private credit’s cycle—but the rules are changing. Fast.
Stay sharp.