Sponsorship: Private Debt News reaches institutional investors, credit professionals, and LP decision-makers. Early sponsor rates available. Contact us here or reply directly to this email.
Traders now put roughly 70% odds on a Fed hike next week. Seventy percent. And if you’re in private credit, an asset class built on floating rate loans to companies already carrying seven turns of leverage, that’s the only number that matters this week. Everything you own reprices off it.
Alberto Gallo isn’t waiting to see how it plays out. The Andromeda Capital co-founder said it plainly. “We’re short everything. We’re short the managers, we’re short the insurers, we’re short the data centers. Not all of them, but the ones that we like the least.” His math ain’t complicated. Private credit investors are pocketing 8 to 9% net in what he calls “the best possible environment for credit.” High yield bonds pay 7 to 8%. That’s the spread you gave up your liquidity for. And if Treasuries clear 5%... “all these investors will realize they’ve invested in something too risky and too illiquid.” The losses, he says, are already there. “The iceberg is already touching the boat.”
And the evidence keeps coming. HLEND capped redemptions at 5% for the third straight quarter, after 11.5% asked out. Thoma Bravo scheduled a lender call this week to refinance Sophos’ $2.1 billion loan due March 2027, after several private credit firms passed on the deal despite a steep bump in yield. The sponsor has roughly $9 billion of software debt coming due, more than any peer, and just conceded forty sweeteners on Proofpoint. FORTY.
In Europe, the lenders everybody called patient are done being patient. Lincoln International counted €4.5 billion of debt foreclosures across eight issuers so far this year, way beyond anything in the last three years. Bad PIK ticked up to 8.1%. “Around 35% of lenders faced repeated amendments before they took control,” Lincoln’s Nick Baldwin said.
And Marblegate bought roughly $2 billion of the Fed’s busted Main Street loans for $516 million. Twenty-five cents on the dollar. Pandemic era loans to mid-sized businesses whose floating rate interest roughly doubled during the hiking cycle. Nearly a quarter of the borrowers defaulted or needed modifications. You want to know what floating rate stress looks like when it finally clears? That’s it.
Key Market Themes
1. Gallo Shorts the Whole Stack Ahead of a Possible Hike
Gallo laid out the bear case on the Credit Edge podcast. Insurers and pensions chasing yield have climbed “a Jenga tower of debt,” trading liquidity for a spread that no longer pays them for it. Net private credit returns of 8 to 9% in ideal conditions barely clear the 7 to 8% sitting right there in high yield bonds. And when your margin is that thin, a modest hit wipes out one or two years of returns. Poof.
Then he went after the insurance channel, which is where the bodies are. “Life insurers are the biggest buyers of private credit. It comes to no surprise that a lot of life insurers are owned by private credit and private equity shops like Athene or Global Atlantic but some of these losses might actually end up on the taxpayer’s balance sheet.” Read that again. The taxpayer. As for the hyperscalers, he ran the numbers. A decade of $1 to 1.5 trillion a year in capex means they have to double current revenues just to break even. “I’m sure they can do it. But I’m not sure they can do it in the next two, three years.” Meanwhile the smaller data centers are still issuing at 200 to 400 basis points. Which makes the short cheap. You’re paying almost nothing to bet against them.
The trade behind the rhetoric
Now here’s the thing. You can’t short a private loan. There’s no bid, no ask, no ticker. So you short the balance sheets holding the loans and the assets the loans financed. Lee Robinson figured this out earlier this year, Gallo is just doing it with more zeros. What’s new is the timing. A hike raises the coupon on loans the borrowers already can’t service. So more of them go PIK. And PIK hides the loss. And the hidden loss is exactly what Gallo is betting on. It’s a loop, and a rate hike tightens it. He’s not calling for a crash, don’t put words in his mouth. He’s saying you can’t earn high yield returns with private market liquidity at a 5% Treasury unless something reprices. And something will.
2. Thoma Bravo’s Lenders Walk From Sophos
Thoma Bravo launched a lender call to amend and extend Sophos’ $2.1 billion loan due March 2027. Commitments due September 22, Goldman leading. They’ve been negotiating for months. And here’s what should stop you cold... several private credit firms passed. After being offered a steep bump in yield. Possible concessions include a higher coupon, amortization, and a tighter covenant package.
Now the context is a $9 billion software maturity pile at Thoma Bravo, more than any other sponsor. Medallia went to the creditors this summer. Proofpoint got its roughly $4.3 billion refinancing done, but it took about forty sweeteners.
When yield stops working
For a decade the entire private credit pitch to borrowers was certainty. Pay up and the money is there. No syndication risk, no flex, no market window. You paid a premium for the handshake. Well, now the handshake wants amortization and covenants on top of the coupon, and some of the lenders still said no. And Sophos is a real business! Cybersecurity. Not some data visualization tool waiting to be eaten by an LLM. If Sophos can’t clear a refi without a syndicated market rescue, what happens to the $9 billion behind it? The dirty little secret is Thoma Bravo went from one of the biggest fee payers in private credit to a name lenders are learning to pass on. They’re not grading the company anymore. They’re grading who owns it.
3. HLEND Gates a Third Time, and Johnson Says Keep Gating
BlackRock’s HPS Corporate Lending Fund capped withdrawals at 5% for the third quarter in a row. Investors asked for 11.5%, down from 13.3% last period, so they’ll tell you that’s progress. The fund reported 9.9% net annualized since inception and says its portfolio companies grew revenue 12.4% over twelve months. Fine. The smaller BDEBT saw 4.6% and paid everybody in full. Blackstone gated again. Cliffwater gated again.
And then Jenny Johnson said the quiet part out loud. The Franklin Templeton CEO told the IPEM conference that paying redemptions above 5% is a mistake even when the fund can afford it. “Then you train people to think ‘Well, I should be able to get my money.’” Her fix? “If you want more liquidity, you need a different vehicle.” Ares’ Blair Jacobson made the counterargument, that floating rates could actually boost returns if the cost of capital rises, and said the roughly 650 companies in the firm’s listed BDC are still growing 8 to 10%.
The industry picks a side
Think about that. The customer wants their money back and the vendor’s position is that giving it to them sets a bad precedent. Remember last spring, when Blackstone tapped its own executives for $150 million to pay 7.9% in full? Everybody applauded. And what did investors learn? That the cap was negotiable. It took exactly one more quarter of rising requests to unlearn that lesson. So the 5% is now doctrine, and the industry has decided the reputational damage from gating is cheaper than the alternative. HLEND’s requests falling from 13.3% to 11.5% is progress of a sort, but at this pace the backlog clears sometime in 2028. As for Jacobson, he’s right. For the lender. Which is precisely the problem for the borrower. The same rate that fattens your coupon is the rate the guy paying it can’t afford.
4. Europe’s Lenders Learn to Take the Keys
Lincoln International’s Q2 European index counts €4.5 billion of debt foreclosures across eight issuers this year, far beyond anything in the last three years. Do the math, that’s over half a billion a name, these are not small companies. Sponsors have “cycled through plan A, B, C all the way to Z,” Lincoln’s Nick Baldwin said. And if you do get another amendment, look at what it costs now. Priority economics. Capex and budget control. Board observer rights. Veto over M&A and any change to the capital structure. That’s not an amendment, that’s a receivership with extra steps. PIK usage rose to 16.7% and bad PIK to 8.1%.
Part of this is cultural. The American managers who set up shop in Europe brought workout teams who want to prove they can do it. “The US, UK and European markets are converging,” said PGIM’s Josh Shipley. Goldman’s March study counted 146 European companies that have handed control to direct lenders since 2017. Liability management exercises remain rare because European documentation is tighter, though the Benelux and Switzerland are apparently warming up to the idea.
The patient lender is gone
Europe was patient because valuations were rising and liquidity was everywhere, and why fight when you can wait? Neither condition holds anymore. Foreclosures at €4.5 billion across eight names means real companies, and 35% of lenders taking control after repeated amendments means the patience ran out on a schedule, not on a whim. Now here’s the irony. Everybody in America uses loose documents to fight their creditors, the LME is a national sport. European docs are tighter, so LMEs are rare. But tight docs cut both ways. The same paper that stops the sponsor from priming you makes it easy for you to enforce. American sponsors fight. European sponsors hand over the keys.
5. Marblegate Buys the Fed’s Wreckage at 25 Cents
Marblegate paid $516 million for roughly $2 billion of what’s left of the Main Street Lending Program. More than 300 borrowers across 40 states. Now the Fed will tell you the program still turns a profit overall, interest and fees offsetting the losses. Okay. But nearly 25% of the borrowers defaulted or renegotiated. These were five year floating rate loans and the interest payments roughly doubled during the hiking cycle. And the Fed couldn’t forgive principal, so anybody who defaulted was left “lost in limbo.”
Marblegate CIO Andrew Milgram knows exactly who he’s about to be negotiating with. “The cost of labor is going up, the cost of input prices are going up. At the same time, they’re trying to raise prices but there’s a lot of pushback.” This is the firm that made money on New York taxi medallions and employee retention tax credits. They buy what everybody else has given up on.
A preview at the small end
So why should you care about a pandemic program? Because it’s a clean experiment. Mid-sized American borrowers, floating rate debt, one hiking cycle. Government backing. A lender that couldn’t even take a principal loss. Best possible conditions. And the result was a quarter of them defaulting and the paper clearing at 25 cents. Private credit’s middle market book is the same borrower. With more leverage. And no Fed. Twenty-five cents is what a sophisticated distressed buyer thinks unsecured mid-market paper is worth when a real bid sets the price. Remember that number the next time a BDC marks a stressed loan at 70.
6. The Unitranche Starts to Unbundle
ABF Journal’s Lisa Rafter laid out why the unitranche era is ending, and the numbers are stark. Median new-issue direct loan spreads went from 716 basis points in March 2023 to 544 at the end of 2025. Covenant-lite went from 4% of direct lending to 21% in two years. Average LBO size went from $200 million in 2020 to $380 million. Fewer deals, bigger deals, tighter pricing, weaker protection. That’s not a healthy market, that’s a market selling the same thing for less.
Three things are pulling the stack apart. One, insurance money, nearly $1.5 trillion and growing 20% a year. Insurers need rated, longer duration paper, and an unrated unitranche isn’t that, so managers carve the senior strip into rated feeders. Two, asset-based finance, which KKR puts at $6.1 trillion today and $9.2 trillion by 2029. ABF prices each asset on its own cash flows, not one enterprise value lien over everything. Three, the spread compression itself. At 544 over you can’t price a single instrument that hits a senior return target and a junior return target at the same time, the math doesn’t work. So the stack layers. Rated senior to the insurers, cash flow term loan to the flagship fund, ABL revolver to a specialty lender. And the mid-tier manager without insurance access? They’re now funding senior risk at junior costs, and that disadvantage compounds every year.
Efficiency correction, not disruption
Rafter’s framing is the right one. The unitranche worked when the capital base was narrow and everybody wanted the same thing. It stops working when a $3 trillion market has insurers and retail evergreens and institutional drawdowns each needing a different risk and rating profile. Unbundling prices each layer for whoever holds it. And who loses? Obvious. A mid-market lender without an insurance affiliate. The barbell everybody predicted, mega-platforms up-market and specialists in the lower middle, gets sharper because the middle tier can no longer compete on cost of capital. This week’s redemption headlines are the cycle. This is the structure underneath. And structure outlasts the cycle.
Deals of Note
Sophos - Thoma Bravo pitching amend-and-extend on the $2.1B loan due March 2027, Goldman leading, commitments due Sept. 22; several private credit firms passed even at a higher yield
Main Street Lending Program - Marblegate paid $516M for ~$2B of Fed pandemic loans across 300+ borrowers, roughly 25 cents on the dollar
Arini - Nearing a $4B final close on its debut European direct lending fund, roughly 13% net IRR and zero software exposure; read that last part twice
Bridgepoint Credit - Moved €1.2B of loans from an older fund into a continuation vehicle
PennantPark - Raised $745M for a private credit continuation fund; continuation vehicles for loans, file that
Blue Owl data center REIT - Planning a blind-pool vehicle seeded with about $6.5B of its own data center assets; Gallo is short the data centers and Blue Owl is selling you a fund of them, one of them is wrong
EIG - Raised $4B across its direct lending platform after a $1.9B close on its latest fund
Jefferies Credit Partners - $4B of European lending capacity anchored by Allianz Global Investors
Palmer Square - $37B credit manager exploring a sale
The Reality Check
The hike connects everything. Floating rate borrowers already on PIK get a higher coupon. Sponsors already handing out forty sweeteners get a tougher room. Insurers already holding unrated unitranche paper get a wider gap between what they own and what the regulator wants them to own. Gallo isn’t forecasting a crash. He’s pointing out that the one variable this asset class never stress-tested is the rate every single loan floats off of. Think about that. A three trillion dollar market built on floating rate paper that never ran the scenario where the rate goes up.
Watch Sophos. It’s a good company and that’s the point. When lenders pass on a real cybersecurity business at a higher yield, they’ve stopped pricing software as a category and started pricing sponsors. Thoma Bravo has $9 billion due and a track record now defined by Medallia. The lenders aren’t punishing the borrower. They’re pricing who owns it.
Europe taking keys and Marblegate paying a quarter are the same event at two stages. First the amendments stop. Then the paper trades. And the Fed’s book just told you what mid-market floating rate paper fetches when someone who has to sell meets someone who actually wants to buy. Twenty-five cents isn’t a forecast for BDC recoveries. It’s a reminder that a mark at 70 is somebody’s optimism. It is not a bid.
And underneath the quarter’s noise, the capital stack is being rebuilt for a market that outgrew its signature product. Rated senior strips to the insurers, ABL revolvers to the specialists, junior risk to the drawdown funds. The unitranche won because it was simple. Simplicity is what a three trillion dollar asset class can no longer afford.